WHATSTHATFISH

Community guidelines

WhatsThatFish works because divers share what they saw and help each other put names to it. Everyone here was a beginner once: be patient, be kind, and help the record get a little better each time.

These sit alongside our terms of use. Seen something that breaks them? Let us know.

The animals come first

  • Never touch, chase, corner, feed or move an animal to get a photo — and never damage coral or the reef to get closer.
  • Mind your buoyancy, fins and kit around the reef; no shot is worth a broken coral.
  • Think before sharing exactly where a very rare or vulnerable animal lives. A dive site is usually fine; a precise spot can bring more attention than it can take.
  • Don’t post photos that show animals being harassed or harmed, except to report it.

Sharing photos and videos

  • Post your own photos, or ones whose licence lets you, credited the way it asks (see photo licensing).
  • Wildlife you saw yourself, in the wild or an aquarium — say which. No memes, adverts, or photos taken from other sites.
  • Fill in the where and when as best you can: the dive site, date and depth make a sighting far more useful to everyone who looks it up later.
  • Ask before posting other people as the subject of a photo; divers in the background are fine. Nothing graphic, explicit or unrelated to marine life.

Identifying

  • Suggest what you honestly think it is, and vote for the suggestion you believe — not the most popular one.
  • Say why: the fin, the pattern, the place, the depth. A reason teaches the next person, and helps the moderator decide.
  • Not sure? Say so. Changing your mind when someone shows you something new is part of it.
  • Moderators make the final call. If you think one got it wrong, explain in the discussion — politely.

Editing species

  • Add what you know to be true, in your own words; mention where it comes from in the note with your edit.
  • Don’t copy text from books, field guides or other websites — it isn’t ours to use.
  • Describe what helps a diver in the water: what it looks like at each stage, where it’s found, what it’s confused with and how to tell them apart.
  • Be careful with safety. Mark something dangerous only when you’re sure, and never call an animal harmless just because it hasn’t hurt you.
  • No vandalism, jokes or promotion. Moderators review changes, and every page keeps its history.

Comments and discussion

  • Be respectful — disagree with ideas, not people. No insults, harassment, threats or hate of any kind.
  • Stay on the subject of the species, photo or article you’re commenting on.
  • No spam, advertising or self-promotion, and don’t share anyone’s personal details.
  • Never tell someone it’s safe to touch or handle an animal.

When things go wrong

Comments from members without a badge wait for a moderator before they appear, and moderators review identifications and edits. Anything that breaks these guidelines may be removed or declined; repeated or serious problems can mean an account is suspended. If you see something that shouldn’t be here, tell us and we’ll look at it.